Analogies and Disanalogies Between Machine-Driven and Human-Driven Legal Judgement
Keywords:Algorithmic decision-making, normativity, rule of law, discretion, feedback loops
Are there certain desirable properties from text-driven law, which have parallels in data-driven law? As a preliminary exercise, this article explores a range of analogies and disanalogies between text-driven normativity and its data-driven counterparts. Ultimately, the conclusion is that the analogies are weaker than the disanalogies. But the hope is that, in the process of drawing them, we learn something more about the comparison between text and data-driven normativities and the (im?)possibility of data-driven law.
Reply by Emily M. Bender, Professor of Computational Linguistics, University of Washington.
How to Cite
Main text and response text copyright © 2020 Reuben BinnsReply text copyright © the replier
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.